Your search for returned the following:

1. Message Cards
Fat Witch offers a selection of unique message and greeting cards. Choose from our selection and add your personal message on the order page

Relevance:

View Page »

2. Cookbook
Inside Fat Witch Brownies, you'll find all of the tantalizing, mouthwatering treats we bake for our New York City store and online orders. Spectacular blondies, anyone? We're known for brownies and our recipe for a moist, dense chocolate-y bar i

Relevance:

View Page »

3. FAQ's
Intense chocolate brownies with varieties including white chocolate, dried cherries, double chocolate, oatmeal and many more. Fat Witch is the first to showcase a bite-sized brownie.

Relevance:

View Page »

4. Info
Intense chocolate brownies with varieties including white chocolate, dried cherries, double chocolate, oatmeal and many more. Fat Witch is the first to showcase a bite-sized brownie.

Relevance:

View Page »

5. Shipping Policy
Intense chocolate brownies with varieties including white chocolate, dried cherries, double chocolate, oatmeal and many more. Fat Witch is the first to showcase a bite-sized brownie.

Relevance:

View Page »

6. Witch Mix
Original Fat Witch Brownie Mix. This is my original brownie recipe

Relevance:

View Page »

7. Witchscopes
Whimsical words of wisdom

Relevance:

View Page »

8. Witch Planet
We're getting greener - Welcome to the Witch Planet - Featuring Witch Ends and Bright Ideas.

Relevance:

View Page »

9. preorder
Inside Fat Witch Brownies, you'll find all of the tantalizing, mouthwatering treats we bake for our New York City store and online orders. Spectacular blondies, anyone? We're known for brownies and our recipe for a moist, dense chocolate-y bar i

Relevance:

View Page »

10. Recipe File January 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

11. Recipe File February 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

12. Recipe File March 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

13. Recipe File May 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

14. Recipe File July 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

15. Bake Sale

Relevance:

View Page »

16. Recipe File September 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

17. Recipe File August 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

18. Recipe File October 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

19. Recipe File November 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

20. witchoffer

Relevance:

View Page »

21. Recipe File December 2016SAVE

Relevance:

View Page »

22. newsletter

Relevance:

View Page »

23. Recipe File December 2015

Relevance:

View Page »

24. Snow Baby Offer

Relevance:

View Page »

25. Recipe File January 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

26. Offer PAGE

Relevance:

View Page »

27. Recipe File May 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

28. Recipe File June 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

29. Recipe File August 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

30. Recipe File October 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

31. sneakpeekwitchscopes

Relevance:

View Page »

32. Trick or Treat

Relevance:

View Page »

33. DecemberOffers

Relevance:

View Page »

34. Tickle Me Pink

Relevance:

View Page »

35. Garden Party

Relevance:

View Page »

36. Favor | information

Relevance:

View Page »

37. Buy Now

Relevance:

View Page »

38. Recipe File March 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

39. Recipe File May 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

40. Recipe File April 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

41. Witch Planet Submit

Relevance:

View Page »

42. Recipe File August 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

43. Recipe File July 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

44. Japan Shop Collection

Relevance:

View Page »

45. Recipe File September 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

46. Recipe File October 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

47. Recipe File January 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

48. Witch Kitchen
Mix Directions. Baking Tips. Add-Ins. More Add-ins. Chocolatology. History of Chocolate.

Relevance:

View Page »

49. Motherdaytreatxxx

Relevance:

View Page »

50. Buy Now Classic

Relevance:

View Page »

51. Recipe File June 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

52. Recipe File May 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

53. Recipe File April 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

54. Recipe File March 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

55. Recipe File February 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

56. Recipe File November 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

57. Recipe File December 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

58. recipes

Relevance:

View Page »

59. Recipe File August 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

60. Recipe File July 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

61. Thanksgiving Treats

Relevance:

View Page »

62. japancollection

Relevance:

View Page »

63. Recipe File October 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

64. Recipe File September 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

65. Recipe File November 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

66. New Year Treats

Relevance:

View Page »

67. Holiday Bag

Relevance:

View Page »

68. Recipe File Cream Cheese Schmear

Relevance:

View Page »

69. Valentine Bag

Relevance:

View Page »

70. Japan

Relevance:

View Page »

71. Recipe File April 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

72. Recipe File June 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

73. Recipe File May 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

74. Recipe File July 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

75. Favor Samples

Relevance:

View Page »

76. Tiny Bag

Relevance:

View Page »

77. Recipe File September 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

78. Recipe File August 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

79. Recipe File October 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

80. Buy Now - Two

Relevance:

View Page »

81. Recipe File November 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

82. Videos

Relevance:

View Page »

83. Favors

Relevance:

View Page »

84. Contact

Relevance:

View Page »

85. Recipe File December 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

86. Holiday X Treats

Relevance:

View Page »

87. Recipe File January 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

88. Add Product

Relevance:

View Page »

89. Recipe File February 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

90. Recipe File March 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

91. Make Your Own Gift

Relevance:

View Page »

92. witchtreats

Relevance:

View Page »

93. Recipe File June 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

94. Recipe File August 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

95. Recipe File July 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

96. Recipe File December 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

97. Multiple Shipping Information

Relevance:

View Page »

98. Recipe File February 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

99. St Patrick's Day Treat

Relevance:

View Page »

100. Motherdaytreat

Relevance:

View Page »

101. NYC Delivery

Relevance:

View Page »

102. testHome

Relevance:

View Page »

103. JulyFourth

Relevance:

View Page »

104. Recipe File September 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

105. Checkout
Fat Witch has gift boxes and gift tins to make the perfect gift.

Relevance:

View Page »

106. DIY Custom

Relevance:

View Page »

107. Recipe File October 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

108. Recipe File May 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

109. Recipe File April 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

110. Recipe File May 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

111. Recipe File August 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

112. Recipe File October 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

113. Recipe File November 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

114. TreatEaster

Relevance:

View Page »

115. Recipe File September 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

116. Trick or Treat Pumpkin

Relevance:

View Page »

117. Unsubscribe

Relevance:

View Page »

118. Sitemap

Relevance:

View Page »

119. Search

Relevance:

View Page »

120. Photo Gallery

Relevance:

View Page »

121. Privacy Policy

Relevance:

View Page »

122. Shipping & Returns

Relevance:

View Page »

123. My Account

Relevance:

View Page »

124. My Wish List

Relevance:

View Page »

125. List Item

Relevance:

View Page »

126. Recipe File March 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

127. Recipe File November 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

128. Recipe File October 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

129. Recipe File March 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

130. Recipe File February 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

131. Recipe File July 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

132. newfaq

Relevance:

View Page »

133. Recipe File March 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

134. Recipe File November 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

135. Recipe File July 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

136. test Halloween

Relevance:

View Page »

137. Recipe File September 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

138. Recipe File December 2016

Relevance:

View Page »

139. Recipe File January 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

140. Recipe File July 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

141. Recipe File February 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

142. Recipe File June 2017

Relevance:

View Page »

143. Stocking Stuffer

Relevance:

View Page »

144. Recipe File December 2018

Relevance:

View Page »

145. Recipe File January 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

146. Recipe File March 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

147. Recipe File February 2019

Relevance:

View Page »

148. revFAQs

Relevance:

View Page »

149. Recipe File June 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

150. Recipe File December 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

151. Recipe File May 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

152. Recipe File September 2020

Relevance:

View Page »

153. Recipe File November 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

154. Recipe File July 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

155. Recipe File January 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

156. Recipe File January 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

157. Recipe File April 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

158. Checkout - Auth.net

Relevance:

View Page »

159. Recipe File August 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

160. Recipe File December 2021

Relevance:

View Page »

161. Recipe File December 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

162. New Add Product

Relevance:

View Page »

163. Recipe File April 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

164. Recipe File January 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

165. Recipe File September 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

166. Recipe File June 2022

Relevance:

View Page »

167. Recipe File August 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

168. Recipe File February 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

169. Recipe File April 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

170. Recipe File June 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

171. Home

Relevance:

View Page »

172. Products

Relevance:

View Page »

173. 2024-NYC Delivery

Relevance:

View Page »

174. 2024-Home Baking

Relevance:

View Page »

175. 2024-About Us

Relevance:

View Page »

176. 2024-BUY NOW TWO

Relevance:

View Page »

177. Recipe File October 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

178. Recipe File November 2023

Relevance:

View Page »

179. 2024-Location

Relevance:

View Page »

180. Shipping Policy 2024

Relevance:

View Page »

181. 2024-My Account

Relevance:

View Page »

182. 2024-SignUp

Relevance:

View Page »

183. 2024-DIY

Relevance:

View Page »

184. 2024-FAQs

Relevance:

View Page »

185. 2024-Favors

Relevance:

View Page »

186. 2024-MultiShipping - Information

Relevance:

View Page »

187. Login

Relevance:

View Page »

188. 2024-Message Cards

Relevance:

View Page »

189. 2024-Favors-Information

Relevance:

View Page »

190. 2024-Favor Samples

Relevance:

View Page »

191. 2024-BUY NOW

Relevance:

View Page »

192. 2024-Nutrition

Relevance:

View Page »

193. 2024-shippingpolicy

Relevance:

View Page »

194. 2024-Privacy-Policy

Relevance:

View Page »

Blonde Witch 4oz
$5.25
The Blonde Witch beckons with its sweet vanilla charm and morsels of chocolate, offering a divine, cookie-like caress in every golden square. 16 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$48.99
This Gift Box is full of our Original All Chocolate Fat Witch Babies Tin of Favs
$42.99

Gift Box filled with 8 Big Brownies, this is a real crowd pleaser.

 

Fat Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
Embark on a chocolate odyssey with our Fat Witch Original, a brownie that's the epitome of cocoa bliss, delivering a classic flavor that bewitches at first taste. Breakfast Witch 4oz
$5.25
The Breakfast Witch offers a morning feast of flavors, combining oatmeal, brown sugar, and walnuts with a coffee kick, all layered over a brownie base. This 4oz treat redefines breakfast indulgence. 36 Assorted Baby Gift Box
$103.99

Great gift for a group. Filled with an assortment of individually wrapped, wickedly good, bite-sized Brownies.

Walnut Baby 1.5oz
$3.25
Nutty Indulgence in a Brownie: Embrace the luxurious texture of our Walnut Baby, where the timeless appeal of our traditional brownie meets the heartiness of walnuts. This creation is a nutty adventure in just 2-3 bites. 24 Assorted Baby Gift Box
$73.99

Enchant the receiver with this Gift Box filled with an assortment of our delicious individually wrapped bite-sized Brownies.

16 Assorted Baby Witch Gift Box
$48.99
Cast a spell with this assorted selection 8 Assorted Baby Witch Gift Box
$25.99

The perfect gift to say thank you.  The box is tied with ribbon and filled with assorted selection of 8 delicious individually wrapped brownies.

Small things come in good packages!

Hannah's Homework
$20.99
8 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$25.99

The perfect gift to say thank you.  The box is tied with ribbon and filled with 8 delicious individually wrapped all chocolate brownies.  Small things come in good packages!

8 Big Witch Box (chocolate only)
$42.99

The Fat Witch logo is front and center on this Gift Box and filled with 8 of New York City's Legendary Fat Witch Brownies. These 8 Fat Witch Original Brownies are bursting with our famous intense chocolate taste. Each is individually wrapped. This Gift Box is available online and at our Chelsea Market store located in the Chelsea section of New York City.

8 Big Witch Sampler Tin
$42.99

This Gift Tin filled with 8 Big Witch Brownies has something to please everyone.

 

Red Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
Discover the enchanting blend of the Red Witch, a 3.5 oz brownie jeweled with succulent dried cherries. The perfect balance of sweet and tart, it's a cherry-kissed chocolate delight. Fat Witch Baby 1.5oz
$3.25
Savor the Spellbinding Delight: Our original Fat Witch Baby brownie, a 1.5oz treasure, offers the perfect portion for blissful indulgence. In just 2-3 bites, be captivated by its deep, rich chocolate essence. Original Brownie Mix
$7.50
This is my original recipe.
Have fun baking and enjoy every magical morsel! Snow Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
The Snow Witch enchants with its velvety white chocolate essence, delivering a wintry whisper of sweetness for a sublime chocolate escape. Walnut Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
The Walnut Witch casts a spell with its rich, chocolate canvas punctuated by the heartiness of walnuts, offering an earthy, satisfying experience. 36 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$103.99
Blonde Baby 1.1oz
$3.25
Bite into Soft Elegance: The Blonde Baby, with its light color and soft texture, Offers a vanilla-flavored escape, enriched with dark chocolate chunks. Savor the unique blend of a brownie and a chocolate chip cookie in just 2-3 bites. 24 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$73.99
This Gift Box is full of our Original All Chocolate Fat Witch Babies Caramel Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
The Caramel Witch bewitches with a sumptuous weave of creamy caramel through intense chocolate, crafting a 3.5oz indulgence that's pure luxury. Double Chocolate Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
Delve into the Double Chocolate Witch's deep, dark, double-layered chocolate fantasy, where every 3.5oz bite is a passage to chocolate paradise. Caramel Witch Ends
$12.99 $12.99
Witch Ends are the parts of brownies that are on the edge of the pan. Some people think the drier edges are the best part.
These Witch Ends are made from our popular caramel brownies Gift Box
$7.99
special packaging
$0.00
Original Witch Ends
$12.99
Get your chocolate fix without the commitment! Out Witch Ends are the perfect treat for those who want a little bit of magic in their day. Brownie ends packaged in a spellbinding witch bag. Because sometimes, you just need a little bite of happiness. Caramel Baby 1.5oz
$3.25
Indulge in Caramel Perfection: Experience the seamless fusion of our classic brownie with a swirl of smooth caramel in the Caramel Baby – a delightful journey in just 2-3 bites. Bake Sale Cookbook #2
$22.99
Emerald City Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
The Emerald City Witch brings a twist of mint to the classic brownie. Each 3.5oz piece is a delightful dance of chocolate and cool mint, whisking you away on a magical, mint-infused journey. Logo Mug
$12.99
It's a Mug to remember New York.
This is a classic New York mug featuring the Fat Witch logo.
The perfect accessory for all lovers of the Fat Witch. Fat Witch Tote Bag
$8.99
You can use this bag over & over again. It's fun, practical and so New York! Box 6 Baby Gold
$15.99
Double Chocolate Baby 1.5oz
$3.25
Choc-full of Delight: The Double Chocolate Baby elevates our original brownie with a generous sprinkle of chocolate chunks, creating a doubly delicious chocolate escapade in every bite. Snow Baby 1.3oz
$3.25
Winter's Sweet Embrace: Indulge in our Snow Baby, a decadent White Chocolate treat made with fresh ingredients and a hint of vanilla. A sweet Winter wonderland delight that's sure to satisfy your cravings! PO Cauldron Special
$27.99
27 Assorted Baby Gift Box
$79.99

This Gift Box is held together by magnets. Magical - just like our brownies! Filled with an assortment of our legendary New York City Baby bite-sized Brownies, each is individually wrapped.
Our 27 Assorted Gift Box includes:
12 Fat Baby Brownies,
3 Walnut Baby Brownies,
3 Blonde Baby Brownies,
3 Caramel Baby Brownies,
3 Snow Babies &
3 Double Chocolate Baby Brownies .

Almond Baby 1.5oz
$3.25
Almond Enchantment in Chocolate: The Almond Baby offers a captivating mix of traditional brownie richness with a bold almond twist. This 1.5oz creation from our Japanese line is a harmonious blend of flavors, featuring the texture and nutty flavor of toasted almond slices and slivers. It delivers a delightful experience with each bite. Japan - Matcha Baby 1.4oz
$3.25
A Whisk to Green Tea Bliss: Discover the Matcha Baby, a 1.4oz gem from our Japanese Collection, blending the tranquil essence of green tea with a creamy white chocolate base. Its cake-like texture, reminiscent of our Snow Baby, offers a delightfully light and indulgent journey. NYC Tiny Bag
$9.00

NYC Tiny Bag Perfect party favor. Filled with 1 Fat Witch Baby and 1 Blonde Baby. NYC Tiny Bag ships flat. An additional bag of Baby Witches will be in the ship-box with instructions.

Classic Cauldron Special
$28.99
Indulge in a witch's brew of flavors with our Classic Cauldron Special! This enchanted box is loaded with a spellbinding assortment of brownie babies, each one a deliciously different treat. Fat, Caramel, Blonde, Walnut, and Double Chocolate - it's a magical mix that will cast a spell of delight on your taste buds! 75 Assorted Baby Gift Box
$199.99

This Gift Box is a Crowd Pleaser. Filled with an assortment of our legendary New York City Baby bite-sized Brownies, each is individually wrapped.

 

75 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$199.00

This Gift Box is a Crowd Pleaser. Filled with our legendary New York City Baby bite-sized Fat Witch Brownie, each is individually wrapped.

96 Assorted Baby Gift Box
$249.99

Plenty for Everyone! Enough to Share! Filled with an assortment of our legendary New York City Baby bite-sized Brownies, each is individually wrapped.
 

96 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$249.99

This Gift Box has enough for Everyone!. Filled with our legendary New York City Baby bite-sized Fat Witch Brownie, each is individually wrapped.

Seasonal Fat Witch Baby 1.5oz
$2.75
***Unwind from the Grind***
$50.00
***DIY YOC
$40.00
***Student Special***
$38.00
Thanksgiving Treat
$27.99
Take-Out gift box filled with 5 Fat Witch Babies with Pilgrim labels and 4 Pumpkin Caramel Babies. BUY NOW - December
$65.99
Treat yourself with our festive holiday boxes! One box is filled with 8 Christmas Fat Witch
Baby Brownies, while the other contains
3 Fat Witch, 2 Caramel, and 3 Walnut.
Enjoy the convenience of USPS shipping at no extra cost-perfect for celebrating the season! Coffee Witch 3.5oz
$5.25
Awaken your senses with the Coffee Witch, a robust 3.5oz brownie that marries intense coffee flavors with mini dark chocolate chips, offering a perfect companion to your espresso. Candy-Easter Treat
$22.99
Custom Gift - 18 Baby Gift Box
$58.99
Custom Gift - 8 Baby Gift Box
$28.00
Special - Party in Red
$54.99
Halloween Baby
$3.25
Meet the Fat Witch Baby, our bewitchingly delicious treat that will cast a spell of chocolatey goodness on your taste buds. Cranberry Baby
$3.25
Baby-sized brownies bursting with tart cranberry flavor. Ginger Baby
$3.25
Valentine Baby
$3.25
Our signature Original Fat Witch Baby, dressed in a special Valentine’s label! Easter Baby
$3.25
27 Fat Baby Gift Box (chocolate only)
$79.99

Magical! - just the brownies.   When you send this gift box you will bedazzle the recipient with 27 of our Legendary Fat Witch Baby individually wrapped brownies. Each with its own intense chocolate taste in every bite.

Red Baby 1.4oz
$3.25
Indulge in the sweet and sassy charm of our Red Baby! This bite-sized treat packs a punch of flavor in every morsel. Rich, velvety chocolate meets tangy cherries in a delightful union that will leave you craving more. Special - Garden Party
$54.99
2 Take-Out boxes: 1 box with 9 Fat with Spring label, 1 box with 3 Fat with Spring label, 2 Snow, 2 Blonde, 2 Caramel Babies. GCS Blonde Witch
$0.00
GCS Fat Witch 3.5oz
$0.00
Cocoa Almond Shortbread
$11.99 $11.99
Our Cocoa-Almond Shortbread is an indulgent treat that combines the finest ingredients to create a truly unforgettable experience. With seven pieces in each package, this decadent delight is perfect for both cookie lovers and chocolate enthusiasts. Buy Now - Classic
$65.99
2 boxes each with 8 assorted brownies, includes free USPS Priority Shipping Order now for a sweet treat! 2 Boxes each containing: 2 Fat Witch Babies, 1 Caramel Baby 1 Walnut babies, 2 Double Chocolate Babies, & 2 Blondie Babies Logo Mug - view 2
$12.99
It's a Mug to remember New York. This is a classic New York mug featuring the Fat Witch logo. The perfect accessory for all lovers of the Fat Witch. MIIR FW Logo Camp Cup
$27.99
Stay caffeinated and show off your love for Fat Witch Bakery with our new insulated camp cup! This 12-ounce mug features our iconic logo and is perfect for coffee, tea, or your favorite hot beverage! 5 Pack Fat Witch Coffee
$9.00 $9.00
Indulge in the rich flavors of our specialty coffee with our 5 pack selection. Perfect for coffee lovers, this assortment offers a delicious taste experience that will leave you wanting more. Each pack contains 5 individual servings, making it easy to enjoy a great cup of coffee at home or on-the-go. Hot Coco - Single B&W
$7.99 $7.99
Warm up with a decadent cup of our signature hot coco, made with the finest ingredients and a touch of magic. Our hot coco is the perfect treat to cozy up with on a chilly day, and will leave you feeling satisfied and comforted. Hot Coco Gift Set
$36.99 $36.99
Treat someone special to the ultimate hot coco experience with our gift set. This beautifully presented package includes everything needed to create a delicious and indulgent hot coco. Perfect for gift-giving or as a thoughtful treat for yourself. Japan - Sesame Baby
$3.25 $3.25
Toasted sesame brownies are a delicious fusion of rich chocolate and nutty toasted sesame seeds, offering a unique flavor and texture. Perfect for those seeking something different! 18 Assorted Baby Magnet Box
$56.99
Want to make a tasteful impression? Send this Gift Bin filled with a delicious assortment of individually wrapped brownies. A yummy selection of favorites. 18 Fat Baby Magnet Box (all chocolate)
$56.99
18 Fat Witch Babies (all chocolate) in a magical magnet box featuring Fat Witch logo. Box of Favs
$42.99
Gift Box filled with 8 Big Brownies, this is a real crowd pleaser. 8 Big Witch Sampler Box
$42.99
This Gift Box filled with 8 Big Witch Brownies has something to please everyone. Peanut Butter Baby
$3.25 $3.25
Creamy Peanut butter meets velvety brownie, a perfect pairing of flavors and textures. Apple Cinnamon Baby
$3.25 $3.25
Enjoy the comforting taste of fresh apples and warm cinnamon blended into a decadent blondie. Perfect for a cozy fall treat! 12 Fat Witch Baby Box
$20.00
Choco Caramel Baby
$3.25

Celebrate Valentine’s Day with this irresistible limited-edition flavor! Our bite-sized chocolate brownie is studded with caramel chips, creating the ultimate treat for caramel and chocolate lovers alike!

Red Velvet Baby
$3.25
Make this Valentine’s Day extra special with our Red Velvet Baby! This mini red velvet brownie is perfectly soft, richly flavorful, and designed for love at first bite.  Treat yourself or share the love with someone sweet! Strawberry Baby
$3.25
Savor the gentle sweetness of our Strawberry Baby! This baby-sized white chocolate brownie has a delicate hint of strawberry, offering the perfect balance of light sweetness. An ideal treat for Valentine’s Day!  Valentine Skyline Box
$15.99
Celebrate love with the Valentine Skyline Box! Featuring a Valentine Fat Witch Baby, 1 Choco Caramel Baby, 1 Strawberry Baby, and 1 Red Velvet Baby, this curated selection is the sweetest way to show your love. Valentine Cauldron
$28.99
Spread the magic of love with our Valentine Cauldron! This festive red box is filled with 2 Valentine Fat Witch Babies, 2 Choco Caramel Babies, 2 Strawberry Babies, and 2 Red Velvet Babies. A spellbinding gift for your Valentine—or a treat to savor yourself.
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.** Lovely Tiny Bags
$59.99
Celebrate love with our Lovely Tiny Bags, filled with a perfect selection of bite-sized brownies ideal for spreading love! Each bag is packed with flavor, making it the perfect Valentine’s Day treat.
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.** Fat Witch for Lovers
$149.99

Celebrate Valentine’s Day with our FW for Lovers – a special 24-count collection, each clear box containing 2 mini brownies. Perfect for sharing with someone special, these sweet treats are the ideal way to spread the love!
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.**

Valentine 16 Baby Gift Box
$48.99
This 16-piece baby brownie gift box brings together classic favorites and limited-edition Valentine flavors. Packed in a red box tied with a ribbon, it’s a heartfelt way to share love—one bite at a time!
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.** Fat Witch Sharable Cubes
$149.99
A perfect treat to share with friends, family, or keep all to yourself! This box of 24 cubics, each with 2 assorted baby brownies inside, offers a variety of delicious flavors that everyone can enjoy, anytime. Whether it’s for a gathering or a cozy moment, these bite-sized brownies are made for sharing!
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.** Witchy Tiny Bags
$59.99
A magical treat in every bag! Each of the 8 tiny bags contains 2 assorted baby brownies, packed with our signature flavors. Perfect for sharing, gifting, or enjoying a little brownie magic, these bags bring joy in every bite!
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.** Cozy Valentine Gift Box
$45.99
Everything you need for a warm and sweet moment! This gift includes 8 delicious baby brownies, 1 rich hot cocoa, and a buttery almond cocoa shortbread, all packed together to create the perfect cozy treat for your Valentine. Share the warmth and love, one bite at a time!
** Shipment Only. No Store Pick Up.** Hot Coco - Single Pink
$7.99
Warm up with a decadent cup of our signature hot coco, made with the finest ingredients and a touch of magic. Our hot coco is the perfect treat to cozy up with on a chilly day, and will leave you feeling satisfied and comforted. St Patrick's Baby
$3.25
Our classic rich brownie, all dressed up for luck! This limited-edition treat comes wrapped in a special leprechaun label, perfect for celebrating the spirit of St. Patrick’s Day. Coffee Baby
$3.25
A rich brownie with a bold coffee kick! This baby-sized treat is perfect for coffee lovers, blending deep chocolate flavor with a hint of coffee. Japan - Yuzu Baby
$3.25
Say hello to Yuzu Baby – a white chocolate-based brownie with a refreshing citrusy twist! Infused with the bright, tangy flavor of yuzu, this soft and delicate treat brings a perfect balance of sweet and zesty. 4 Baby Zen Box
$15.99
A taste of harmony in every bite! The Zen Skyline Box brings together four unique flavors: the classic Fat Witch Baby, nutty Sesame Baby, earthy Matcha Baby, and bright, citrusy Yuzu Baby. A beautifully curated gift inspired by Japanese flavors. 8 Baby Zen Box
$26.00
Twice the flavor, double the joy! The 8 Baby Zen Box features Japanese-inspired flavors with two of each: Classic Fat Witch Baby, nutty Sesame Baby, earthy Matcha Baby, and bright, citrusy Yuzu Baby. A perfect gift for those who love balance and variety.